“Voter ID” Supporters: Put Your Money Where Your Mouth Is.
September 26, 2012


The In August of 1965, President Johnson signed “The Voting Rights Act” into law. It was considered a continuation of his landmark “Civil Rights Act” signed the year before because it was obvious that simply “declaring” that minorities as “equal” to whites was meaningless so long as they could be discriminated against at the ballot box. Among the things made “illegal” by the Act were “poll taxes”, which were intended specifically to discourage poor… disproportionately black… people from voting. And now, 47 years later, Republicans claiming a need to “protect the integrity of the voting process”, have placed a series of obstacles and ID Requirements in the way that for all intents & purposes amount to an illegal “poll tax”… just what the 1965 law sought to end.

I actually read a Tweet from one angry Conservative months ago that exclaimed:

“If someone is too lazy to get to the DMV [for a free photo-ID], they don’t deserve to vote!”

I felt it necessary to point out that it is MUCH easier to “get to the DMV” IF YOU ALREADY HAVE A DRIVERS LICENSE and a car. If you’re working for Minimum Wage, take public transportation to get to work, and can’t afford to take a day off to get to your “local” DMV and wait in line all day for a “free” Voter-ID just to do what you’ve already done for years without incident, suddenly it’s not quite so effortless (of course, with a 140-character Twitter limit, my actual response was closer to: “Dumbass!”)

One Pennsylvania blogger conducted a little experiment to see just how much it would cost the 18% of Philadelphia’s registered black voters that currently do not posses an “acceptable” Photo-ID to obtain one:

  • First off, you’ll need your Social Security Card. If you don’t have one, you can order one for $8.00.
  • Grab your birth certificate with raised stamp, or certificate of citizenship or naturalization. Don’t have yours? That’s another $19.00
  • Two proofs of residency like lease agreements, utility bills, W-2 forms, etc. Unemployed & Homeless? Tough luck.
  • Head to the DMV! Of course, if you had a drivers license, you wouldn’t need a “Voter ID”. Since you can’t drive, you’ll probably be taking public transportation: Roughly $4 roundtrip (and let’s hope the bus drops you off nearby if you’re disabled or have trouble walking).
  • DMV’s are not open weekends. Taking time off from work? Go on your lunch-hour to minimize time lost, but the lines will be longer. Plan on Two & 1/2 hours lost (including travel time) at a minimum wage job: $18.12.

(And may I point out, you don’t need “a birth certificate” or prove citizenship to purchase a drivers license that allows you to vote, yet you need one to get a “free” Voter ID. You don’t even have to be a citizen to get a “drivers license”, so why do you need to prove “citizenship” for an equivalent government-issued photo ID?)

Minimum cost to obtain an ID if you are unemployed, have all necessary documentation and take public transportation: $4.00.
Cost if you need to obtain paperwork (in PA), take time off from work, and take public transportation: $49.12.
Cost for an unemployed/homeless person to vote: Priceless… literally. No bills? No W2? No ID. Number of homeless vets in this country: Approximately 75,000.

Of course, that upper-end cost could be MUCH higher if it takes you more than two hours away from work, make more than minimum wage, and/or need to take a cab because there is no bus stop near your home or the DMV (and double all that if you’re told you’re missing documentation and must make a second trip another day). But for some people, “time off from work” is not an option. I’ve worked temporary jobs where if you missed a day, you needent bother coming in tomorrow.

The solution to this nonsense is really quite simple: If the “Secure the Vote” crowd REALLY believes we need “Voter ID” and REALLY believe it’s not a burden to expect voters to jump through dozens of hoops just to get a “free” ID, then how about we pass a law promising “110% reimbursement” for any costs incurred obtaining a Voter ID? Cab/bus fare, time off from work, documentation, etc. They don’t want to pay people to go door-to-door distributing ID’s or send ID’s through the mail to people who apply by phone or online… which would be the ONLY ways to provide voters with an ID in a way that isn’t a burden (and not every person has a door to knock on, a mailbox to fill, or a phone to call from.) If they balk, it can ONLY be because they don’t want to reimburse anyone… an implicit acknowledgement that obtaining an ID isn’t “free” and may cost many people a lot of money… which makes it an illegal poll tax.

And just for fun…

Batman 1966: The Penguin sings his campaign song
[flv:http://www.mugsysrapsheet.com/4blog/video/Batman-Penguin_campaign_song_w_subs.flv http://www.mugsysrapsheet.com/4blog/video/Batman-Penguin_campaign_song_w_subs.jpg 512 348]

…continuing from the earlier video found at this post: “Am I Supposed to be Impressed Both Ryan and Romney Paid Less Than 20% in Taxes?”

(As you may have noticed, M.R.S. is stepping up it’s reporting as we near election day, so be sure to check back often… or better yet, Register for instant email notification of updates! – Mugsy)

Writers Wanted
Got something to say? Mugsy’s Rap Sheet is always looking for article submissions to focus on the stories we may miss each week. To volunteer your own Op/Ed for inclusion here, send us an email with an example of your writing skills & choice of topic, and maybe we’ll put you online!

RSS Please REGISTER to be notified by e-mail every time this Blog is updated! Firefox/IE users can use RSS for a browser link that lists the latest posts! RSS



September 26, 2012 · Admin Mugsy · 3 Comments - Add
Posted in: Crime, Election, Politics, Racism, Right-wing Facism, Taxes, voting

3 Responses

  1. Grant in Texas - September 26, 2012

    Of 254 counties in Texas, over 80 of our predominately rural counties have NO DMV offices where can one get a photo ID meaning those living in these counties (many also poor) might have to drive over 100 miles to get one. For those not acquainted with Texas, many of our counties are bigger than some of our smaller states like Delaware and Rhode Island. Harris County (Houston) is nearly 1800 square miles compared to 1214 square miles of land in Rhode Island. Brewster County in West Texas has over 6000 square miles which is bigger than Connecticut. It has just under 10,000 population, mostly Latino ranch workers.

    Back in the 1970’s I needed a passport for an overseas job and had to drive the 1100 miles from my Texas home to the courthouse in Indiana where my birth certificate is filed. When I got there, I stood in line for awhile until a clerk could go back into a vault room (with big fireproof steel door) to make a COPY of my certificate (which BTW I have NEVER seen). I bought several Certificates of Live Birth just in case I needed another copy (with a raised seal) again. Back then they were a bargain at $5 each but my 2200 mile road trip to get them cost a thousand dollars more.

    I was born at home as was most of my generation in rural America over 70 years ago. My family called a doctor to the house but many babies were delivered by mid-wives. To this day, in Hispanic South Texas, mid-wives still deliver babies at home. They often don’t record the births at the courthouse.

    I agree with Elisabeth Hasselbeck on “The View” that by 2016 maybe photo ID’s should be required, but even a right winger like her believes that dropping such laws so close to this election was not right. Plus, the government should do everything in its power to get out these photo ID’s at NO COST to the recipients. I remember a few years back when National ID Cards were being discussed then hearing the many conspiracists on the right being very much against this “BIG BROTHER” action. They cited such conspiracies that such ID cards would be used by the government to “round up” dissidents (THEM!) and move them to “work camps”.

  2. Mugsy - September 26, 2012

    Yes, the threat of a “National ID Card” was born out of President Clinton’s health care reform plan, where he held up a credit-card sized “ID” during his first State of the Union Address in 1994 suggesting you could store all of your medical records on such a card, and obtain “free” care at any hospital in the country simply by presenting your “National Care Card”.

    Conspiracy Theorists on the Right went nuts, complaining of “privacy” concerns, even suggesting such an ID was the predicted “Mark of the Beast” foretold in the Bible.

  3. Analysis | Voter ID Laws: Improving the Integrity of the Electoral System or Disenfranchising Voters? - October 23, 2012

    […] http://mugsysrapsheet.com/2012/09/26/voter-id-supporters-put-your-money-where-your-mouth-is/ […]

Leave a Reply